CU, CUF & TPC File Amicus Brief In Navarro v. United States (Executive Privilege)
Dr. Peter K. Navarro served as a senior advisor to President Donald Trump throughout his first term of office. Roughly one year after Trump left office, the House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the U.S. Capitol (“J6 Committee”) served Navarro with a subpoena for documents and to appear for a deposition. Navarro did not produce any documents nor did he appear for the deposition. Instead, he responded stating “President Trump has invoked Executive Privilege in this matter . . . . Accordingly, my hands are tied.” Three months later Navarro was indicted for contempt of Congress.
The statute under which Navarro was charged, 2 U.S. C. § 192, makes it a crime to “willfully” fail to comply with a subpoena. In pre-trial proceeding, the U.S. District Court refused to allow Navarro to defend on grounds that he had a good faith belief that President Trump had invoked Executive Privilege with respect to the matter and he was therefore prohibited from producing records to testifying on the matter. Thereafter, Navarro was convicted and served a four-month jail term.
In upholding Navarro’s conviction, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia relied largely on a 1961 case in which a panel of the D.C. Circuit held that a defendant’s good faith belief was not a defense to the willfulness element of the contempt of Congress offense.
The issue presented by Navarro’s Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the U.S. Supreme Court asks whether the statute at issue requires the government to prove that the defendant knew his conduct was unlawful in order to meet the willfulness element of the offense.
Citizens United’s amicus brief seeks to put the willfulness issue in the case in proper context. The brief first points out that the District Court and Appeals Court refused to consider the J6 Committee failure to take reasonable steps to address the Executive Privilege issue with then Former President Trump, which is a customary practice encouraged by Supreme Court precedent. Second, the brief argues that the good faith defense that Navarro sought to raise is justified to support the purpose behind Executive Privilege as reflected in the Supreme Court’s precedents on the issue. Third, the Court of Appeals erred in ruling that the District Court correctly determined that Executive Privilege did not apply in the matter. And fourth, Navarro had good reason to belief that he had no duty to comply with the Congressional subpoena.
The Supreme Court will likely decide early next year whether to take up Dr. Navarro’s appeal.